Premium Cigars

  • Out StockMicallef ConnecticutQuick View

    Micallef Connecticut

    $168.00

    Origin – Honduras

    Filler – Dominican Republic/Honduras/Nicaraguan

    Binder – Honduras

    Wrapper Type – Varied

  • Esteban Carreras Mr. Brownstone Habano

    $162.00

    The jury is still out on the overall character of this terrific edition. Some say its full bodied right out of the gate. Others claim it starts off on a solid medium level and quickly increases in strength as you move along. Either way, this complex stick yields flavor offerings of savory chocolate, notes of spices, cocoa and that vintage tobacco sweetness on the backend. We await your verdict! Enjoy this cigar BIG TIME!

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    EP Carrillo DuskQuick View

    EP Carrillo Dusk

    $135.90$189.00

    Don’t be afraid of the dark! This edition is probably one of the best examples of why Ernesto Carrillo is the Master Blender he is.

    Achieving a 92 rating and placing in the top 25 cigars of 2017 was well deserved. This super slow burning edition is jammed pack with tobacco and yields a smooth, creamy and slightly sweet medium to full bodied flavor that is balanced and can be enjoyed by everyone.

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Nicaragua

    Binder – Ecuadorian

    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf

  • EP Carrillo New Wave Connecticut

    $101.70$179.10

    You enjoy smooth and creamy, mild to medium bodied cigars and want to see why everyone loves Ernesto Carrillo. Bingo! You found it! This sticks great aroma and ample draw will allow you to experience a refined, balanced and slightly sweet tobacco taste that has become one of this Master Blenders great offerings to many smokers with taste preferences like you!

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Dominican – Nicaraguan

    Binder – Nicaraguan

    Wrapper Type – Ecuador Connecticut

  • Trader Jacks Original

    $35.64$65.88

    You’re probably wondering why a machine made, short filler, domestic cigar would be so popular with Premium Smokers.  Every now and again, a product comes along that serves its purpose and completes its mission. When J.C. Newman created Trader Jacks Classic “Kickin” bagged and jarred editions many years ago, it took awhile to get noticed. As they found their way into humidors across the country, curiosity got the better of many folks that opened the containers and took a sniff. And that was that! The intoxicating aroma these sticks gave off led to a try which then led to buying the whole container. Without getting too involved, Trader Jacks by JC Newman is mellow to slightly medium bodied. They’re all infused resulting in a smooth, sweet, rum like flavor that’s thoroughly enjoyable any time of the day. They keep fresh in their containers and have a totally guilt free price offering any smoker a great diversion.

    WRAPPER: Ecuador Havana Seed
    FILLER: Dominican and Nicaraguan
    FACTORY: J.C. Newman El Reloj/USA

  • Tatuaje Miami

    $169.99$337.50

    This cigar is probably one of the best examples of Just how smart Founder Robert Johnson is. The Miami edition represents some of the best Master Blending skills that famed cigar maker Don Pepin Garcia offers. We’ve often heard about “Cuban Seed” tobacco. As good as that crop generally is, as the seeds continue to get replicated, they lose some of their original growing traits. Rarely are first generation seeds of this calibre found and used and that’s exactly what has made this stick so highly coveted. Yes, this is a medium-full bodied smoke that’s uniquely complex as we’ve come to expect from Tatuaje. But this one offers an unduplicated taste that stands alone. Get them when we have them. They’re worth more than they cost. Enjoy…BIG TIME!

    Origin – United States
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Ecuador Habano – Oscuro

  • Cabaiguan by Tatuaje

    $135.00$226.80

    Since its launch in 2003, Pete Johnson’s Tatuaje cigar portfolio has grown to include more than 20 brands—both in regular and limited production and has grown from unknown status to one of the cigar industry’s highly rated and sought-after boutique cigar brands. Johnson himself has also evolved from an unknown newcomer to visionary and respected industry entrepreneur.
    The Cabaiguan brand has been made for Johnson by the Garcia family since 2006, first in Miami and later in Nicaragua where it is produced today. While Pete’s sticks usually range from solidly medium to full bodied in taste, this 92 rated pigtailed edition’s strength sits squarely in the middle on the medium spot. It’s smooth and balanced with an enjoyable mix of sweetness and spice that’s not overpowering to it’s finish. This blend attracted and introduced many new smokers into the Tatuaje fold.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Broadleaf – Ecuador Connecticut

  • Tatuaje Black

    $153.00$220.00

    Since its launch in 2003, Pete Johnson’s Tatuaje cigar portfolio has grown to include more than 20 brands—both in regular and limited production and has grown from unknown status to one of the cigar industry’s highly rated and sought-after boutique cigar brands. Johnson himself has also evolved from an unknown newcomer to visionary and respected industry entrepreneur.
    This Black edition was very elusive to most folks for a long while. After an exhausting series of sporadic releases, it’s nice to know you can get it on our site. This 92 rated, full bodied Nicaraguan puro wears a dark, oily, aged sun grown Criollo wrapper encasing a very interesting blend of fillers and binder. The result is smooth and strong smoking experience that actually yields a sweetness reminiscent of a nice red wine! The petite lancero is my favorite.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Nicaraguan
    Wrapper Type – Criollo

  • Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua

    $118.32$232.58

    Founded by Rafael Nodal and launched in 2011, Aging Room cigars are made by Jochy Blanco of Tabacalera La Palma in Tamboril, Dominican Republic. Some Aging Room brands are also produced in Nicaragua by Nestor Plasencia Jr. and A.J. Fernandez. All three cigar makers are considered Master Blenders to say the least. The brand’s portfolio includes several high-scoring cigars across many lines.

    There are a lot of different Aging Rooms made in different factories as you can see on our site. This stunning cigar was the ultimate vision of Rafael Nodal and was crafted by A.J. Fernandez in Nicaragua. Rated at 96 and the best cigar in 2019, leaving even the Cuban competitors in the dust. This medium-full bodied Nicaraguan purebred is astounding on all fronts. If you’re a fan of Aging Room, consider this cigar the brand’s crowning achievement. Enough said!

    Origin – Nicaragua

    Filler – Nicaraguan

    Binder – Nicaraguan

    Wrapper Type – Nicaraguan

  • Alec Bradley Taste of the World Sampler

    $49.50

    Alec Bradley Taste of the World Sampler is a fantastic collection of this company’s best cigars.

    What can you say about this group of cigar super stars? If you’ve never enjoyed Alec Bradley cigars, what are you waiting for? No need to check these winners out. Each one is highly rated and hugely popular to say the least. Weather you want to try them yourself or are looking for a perfect gift, this sampler checks all the boxes. And don’t forget, these ship free!

    This Alec Bradley Taste of the World Sampler gift box comes to you with one each of the following incredible cigars in a beautiful gift box:

    – Tempus Nicaragua Medius 6 (6” x 52) 90-rated

    – MAXX The Culture Toro (6” x 54) 91-rated

    – Nica Puro Rosado Toro (6” x 52) 91-rated

    – Black Market Toro (6” x 50) 90-rated

    – Prensado Gran Toro (6” x 54) 96-rated

    – Magic Toast Toro (6” x 52) 95-rated

    See all the Alec Bradley cigars available at The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Rocky Patel Vintage 2006 San AndreasQuick View

    Rocky Patel Vintage 2006 San Andreas (11y)

    $195.30$239.40

    No one disputes that Rocky Patel is one of the few Titans of the Premium Cigar Industry. Over 20 years ago as he began his quest to get a foothold in the marketplace he actually got in his car and traveled the country visiting high volume Tobacconists unannounced! When he wound up in my store to sell his first entry , I hesitantly took a chance on him. Actually, he was such a nice and appreciative person I couldn’t resist! The rest is cigar history!

    If you’ve read my posts you know I’m bullish on aging your cigars to enhance their taste. What sets this Vintage edition apart from the others is the 11 year old San Andreas Mexican wrapper along with Nicaraguan fillers and Connecticut Broadleaf binder. This highly rated, expertly made combination produces a solid medium to full bodied taste that contains coffee and chocolate flavors.

    Origin – Nicaragua
    Filler – Nicaraguan
    Binder – Connecticut Broadleaf
    Wrapper Type – San Andres