My Cart 0

Premium Cigars

  • JM Nicaragua Maduro

    JM Nicaragua Maduro is one of the very popular entries from this iconic company.

    With attention to detail, these very affordably priced smokes proudly possess a near black Connecticut Broadleaf binder along with aged Dominican and Nicaraguan fillers. Encasing these leaves is a beautiful San Andres Mexican dark and oily Maduro wrapper. The results is a very tasty medium to slightly full bodied smooth smoking hearty tasting cigar. The bonus is the aromatic smoke and the subtle overall sweetness.

    Wrapper: San Andres Mexican Maduro
    Binder:USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican Republic and Nicaraguan

    See all the JM Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • JM Nicaragua Sumatra

    $169.00

    JM Nicaragua Sumatra is yet another one of the very popular entries from this iconic company.

    With attention to detail, these very affordably priced smokes proudly possess a near black Connecticut Broadleaf binder and aged Dominican fillers. Encasing these leaves is a beautiful Indonesian Sumatran wrapper. Oddly enough, this blend produces a mild to medium bodied smoke. Think earthy, cinnamon notes with a slightly sweet aftertaste. The combination of quality, flavor, and price make this one an irresistible smoke.

    Wrapper: Indonesian Sumatran
    Binder:USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican Republic

    See all the JM Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • JM Dominican Corojo

    $139.00

    JM Dominican Corojo is one of the very popular entries from this iconic company.

    With attention to detail, these very affordably priced smokes proudly possess a near black Connecticut Broadleaf binder and aged Dominican fillers. Encasing these leaves is a beautiful Dominican Habano wrapper. The results is a very tasty medium to full bodied bodied cigar. Think hints of pepper, cedar wood, and cocoa powder, offering a slightly spicy overall quality with just a bit of peppery smoothness.

    Wrapper: Dominican Republic Habano
    Binder:USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican Republic

    See all the JM Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    JM Dominican Connecticut
    Quick View

    JM Dominican Connecticut

    $117.00$139.00

    JM Dominican Connecticut is probably the most popular blend in this company’s portfolio.

    With attention to detail, these very affordably priced smokes contain a near black Connecticut Broadleaf binder and aged Dominican fillers. Encasing these leaves is a beautiful Ecuadorian grown Connecticut wrapper. In short, this is JM’s mildest blend. But it’s also very tasty with a mellow bodied creamy, smooth flavor. At just over $3, they can be enjoyed every day for sure. Whether you pick the 5 x 50 Robusto or the 6.75 x 50 Churchill, you can count on the following: consistent burn, great draw and a very pleasant aroma.

    Wrapper: Ecuadorian grown Connecticut
    Binder:USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican Republic

    See all the JM Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • JM Dominican Sumatra

    $112.00$129.50

    JM Dominican Sumatra is one of the very popular entries from this iconic company.

    With attention to detail, these very affordably priced smokes contain a near black Connecticut Broadleaf binder and aged Cuban Seed Dominican fillers. Encasing these leaves is a beautiful Indonesian Sumatra wrapper. The results is a very tasty mild to medium bodied cigar. At just over $3, they can be enjoyed every day for sure. Whether you pick the 5 x 50 Robusto or the 6.75 x 50 Churchill, you can count on the following: consistent burn, great draw and pleasant flavor notes. Think cocoa powder, coffee beans, a bit of peppery spice, and some caramel cream.

    In other words, how can you go wrong? Oh yes….did we mention that all JM cigars are pre cut for your convenience! Grab a box of JM Cigars and see why they’ve been a favorite pick for almost 30 years!

    Wrapper: Indonesian Sumatran
    Binder:USA Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Dominican Republic grown Cuban Seed

    See all the JM Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Viaje Private Keep

    $436.99

    Viaje Private Keep Line is a collection of cigars reserved for the most discerning aficionados.

    With attention to detail, each of these cigars is of impeccable quality offering exquisite flavor. These gems are quickly becoming a prized addition to many connoisseur’s collections. In short, Private Keep represents the pinnacle of excellence of Viaje’s cigar making. Consisting only of the finest tobaccos from the most prestigious growing regions around the world, Private Keep must be kept in your humidor!

    From the moment you light up a symphony of flavors dance across the palate. Think notes of rich earthiness, subtle spices, and a hint of sweetness that lingers long after the last draw. To say the least, a flawless smoking experience from start to finish.

    See all the Viaje Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

     

  • Naked by Kafie 1901 Bundles

    $90.00

    Naked by Kafie 1901 Bundles are one of this boutique company’s best entries.

    Naked Bundles are available in three distinct blends; Connecticut, Maduro and Habano. The result is a complex, smooth smoking blend no matter which style you choose. Each one delivers a symphony of flavors. Think notes ranging from earthy and woody to subtle hints of spice and sweetness. All this providing a nuanced and deeply satisfying smoking experience for any smoker.

    With a 90 rating from Cigar Authority and a score of 91 from Cigars and Spirits, these terrific cigars are a must try for lovers of small batch offerings.

    Each one comes in 4 popular sizes of 20 count bundles.

    See all the Kafie 1901 cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

     

  • Kafie 1901

    $210.00$310.00

    Kafie 1901 cigars represent the rich heritage and meticulous craftsmanship combining the finest tobacco harvested from select regions across the globe. Each Kafie 1901 cigar is meticulously hand rolled by skilled artisans, ensuring a flawless construction, perfect draw and consistent burn.

    With attention to detail, the heart of the 1901 cigars is the selection of tobacco. The brand’s portfolio includes a variety of blends, each designed to cater to diverse palates. From the smooth and creamy Connecticut, with its subtle nuances of nuts and cream, to the robust and spicy San Andres and DF Maduro lines presenting bold, full-bodied options. To say nothing of the pleasant and flavorful Sumatra and Serie L Naturals.

    Whether you consider yourself an aficionado or just a lover of small batch true boutique brands, Kafie 1901 must be in your humidor!

    DF Maduro
    Wrapper: Habano Nicaraguan Maduro
    Binder: Authentic African Cameroon
    Filler: Dominican, Pennsylvania, Nicaraguan, Andullo
    Nominated Best Value Honduran Cigar by Cigar Journal [2018]

    Connecticut
    Wrapper:Ecuadorian Grown Connecticut
    Binder: Dominican Republic Cibao Valley
    Filler: Dominican Republic Cibao Valley and Nicaragua
    Nominated as a BEST BUY by Cigar Journal [2014]

    Sumatra
    Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sun Grown Sumatran
    Binder:Dominican Republic Cibao Valley
    Filler: Dominican Republic Cibao Valley, Nicaragua, Peru
    Nominated Best Value Honduran Cigar by Cigar Journal [2021]

    San Andres
    Wrapper: San Andres Mexico
    Binder: Nicaragua
    Filler: Nicaraguan Esteli, Jalapa, Condega
    Nominated Best Value Honduran Cigar by Cigar Journal [2019 + 2020]

    Serie L Natural
    Wrapper: Dominican Republic Corojo Cibao Valley
    Binder:Dominican Republic Cibao Valley
    Filler: Dominican Republic Cibao Valley
    Nominated Best Value Honduran Cigar by Cigar Journal [2023]
    Nominated Best Boutique Honduran Brand by Cigar Journal [2023]

    See all the Kafie 1901 cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Liga Undercrown by Drew Estate

    $190.00$295.00
  • Garo 1887

    $85.00$105.00

    Garo 1887 is another one of the great company’s spectacular entries.

    The 1887 cigar, pays homage to the brand’s rich tradition and dedication to excellence, embodying the essence of premium tobacco craftsmanship.  The 1887 is meticulously blended and crafted to deliver a balanced and complex flavor profile.

    Wrapped in a rich Ecuadorian Habano leaf and bound with the signature Olor Dominican binder, the 1887 offers a distinct experience from start to finish. With attention to detail, the filler is a blend of Dominican Seco/Lijero and Corojo of exceptional quality.  These wonderful cigars produce notes of walnut, honey, cedar, and leather with a velvety texture provided by the Habano wrapper. The construction of these cigars is exemplary, ensuring an even burn and a smooth, consistent draw.

    No doubt the 1877 is just as appreciated by aficionados as they are to newcomers.

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Garo 20th Anniversary

    $120.00$140.00

    The Garo 20th Anniversary is a luxurious embodiment of more than two decades of dedication and expertise in crafting the finest cigars.

    With attention to detail, this cigar combines a Corojo wrapper encasing a Olor Dominican binder along with a special blend of fillers. Without a doubt, you can expect a layered experience of flavor notes. Think coffee, leather, soft baking spices, alongside an earthy and nutty core. The result is the culmination of a long, smooth finish reminiscent of a fine single malt a bold and complex profile that is both rich and nuanced.

    The 20th Anniversary is Garo Cigars’ way of expressing gratitude to their loyal fans. This cigar stands as a token of the rich heritage and exceptional quality that Garo Cigars is renowned for. Whether for a seasoned smoker or a newcomer, this cigar is the one to try!

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Garo 25th Anniversary Eternity Series

    $130.00$190.00

    The Garo 25th Anniversary Eternity Series is a celebratory collection embodying the essence and culmination of twenty-five years in cigar making.

    With attention to detail, the Eternity Series features an Ecuadorian Habano leaf encasing a complex blend of Dominican Olor binder and Nicaraguan filler tobaccos. This combination crafts an overall taste that is both rich and robust, yet remarkably smooth. No doubt the flavor profile is elegantly complex. The result is a subtle spiciness with classic nutty characteristics reminiscent of old Havana. In other words, this 25th Anniversary delivers a sophisticated and elegant smoking experience. In fact, this cigar possesses an exclusively different character from all other Garo Cigars blends. The creation of this cigar is a culmination of all the Garo Cigars blends introduced to the industry. The 25th Anniversary cigar stands on its own for sure.

    So if you consider yourself an aficionado or just an enthusiastic newcomer, this great cigar should be on your radar. At just over $5.00, the #4 is a way to try an amazing smoke that’s worth twice the price!

    Wrapper: Ecuador (Habano)
    Binder: Dominican Republic (Olor)
    Filler: Nicaragua

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

     

  • Garo Maduro Especial

    $120.00$140.00

    The Garo Maduro Especial is the only edition of the company’s portfolio offering a vintage grade dark and oily wrapper.

    With attention to detail, the exquisite maduro wrapper envelopes a meticulously curated blend of premium fillers and binders sourced from the finest tobacco regions. The result is a burst of flavors engaging the senses immediately. This characteristic allows savoring the intricate balance of sweet and spicy notes that define this exceptional blend. Without a doubt, this cigar delivers a fuller-bodied experience, showcasing the blend’s richness and depth,

    From the initial notes of dark chocolate and espresso that greet the smoker, to the evolving layers of caramel sweetness, pepper spice, and the subtle earthiness that follows, every puff is a testament to the blend’s exquisite composition. The Garo Maduro Especial is more than a cigar; it is an experience, a celebration of the art and tradition of cigar making. The Maduro Especial offers a sanctuary of taste.

    To say the least, if you’re a maduro lover, this cigar should be in your humidor.

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

    Learn more about Garo Cigars HERE

  • Garo Blue

    $200.00$230.00

    Garo Blue is a gateway to a luxurious smoking experience to satisfy the desires of the most discerning aficionados.

    With attention to detail, at the heart of this cigar lies a carefully composed blend of the finest aged tobaccos. The result is a medium-bodied experience that bridges complexity with accessibility. With a mild bodied flavor, and wrapped in a golden brown Connecticut shaded wrapper, Garo Blue smokes smoothly and maintains the same consistency through and through. Delicious flavors of nuts culminate in a lingering cedar-like light finish. The solid ash almost refuses to fall off from this hand-crafted masterpiece.

    Without a doubt, the Garo Blue’s construction is a testament to the artisanship of its makers. This quality ensures an even burn and a flawless draw from start to finish. The impeccable construction not only enhances the smoking experience but also serves as a reminder of the dedication to quality that defines the Garo brand.

    If you’ve never tried a Garo, this is this one for sure!

    Wrapper – Connecticut

    Binder – Olor Domincano

    Filler – Creol 98, HBA (Todo Seco)

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Garo HGB San Andreas

    $110.00$150.00

    Garo HGB San Andreas is the culmination of years of dedication to the craft, a celebration of the rich heritage of tobacco cultivation and cigar manufacturing.

    With attention to detail, the HGB San Andreas wrapper encapsulates a blend of the finest Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers. The result is a medium to full-bodied cigar delivering a symphony of flavors, expertly balanced to offer a smooth, yet profoundly engaging smoking experience. From the very first draw, this cigar interweaves notes of dark chocolate, espresso, and a hint of spice. Think layers of leather, earth, and a subtle sweetness emerge, creating a rich tapestry of tastes evolving with each puff. The impeccable construction ensures an even burn and a consistent delivery of flavors.

    Elevate your cigar collection with the HGB San Andreas. Without a doubt, this cigar is a symbol of sophistication and a tribute to the timeless art of cigar making. Let the HGB San Andreas be your guide to discovering the profound pleasures that only a cigar of this caliber can provide.

    See all of the Garo cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • La Palina Family Series

    $170.00$185.00
  • Colibri Quantum Lighter

    $195.00
  • Colibri Butane

    $23.99$24.99