Premium Cigars

  • CAO World: Nicaragua

    $142.02$143.82

    CAO World: Nicaragua is one of this company’s very popular World Series.

    All the fillers in this spectacular cigar all come from Nicaragua, specifically Condega, Estelí and Jalapa. The Honduran wrapper and binder comes from the Jamastran Valley.

    While the jury’s still out deciding if this edition is either medium to full bodied or just flat out full flavored from the get go, what has been decided is this 90+ rated cigar is the most uniquely tasting one of the entire series. It’s generally agreed this darker cigar is robust and spicy. But who would have thought that a two country blend could produce a spearmint undertone in its overall taste bouquet?!

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: Honduran (Jamastran)
    Binder: Honduran (Jamastran)
    Filler: Nicaraguan (Esteli, Jalapa, Condega)
    Factory: STG Esteli
    Blender: Rick Rodriguez

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO World: ItaliaQuick View

    CAO World: Italia

    $147.42$179.82

    CAO World: Italia is one of this company’s very popular World Series.

    The addition of rarely grown Italian long filler leaves to this cigar’s mix produces a highly rated full bodied, thickly sweet and spicy, bold masterpiece. Cigar Aficionado rates this jewel a very respectable 92. Their description is spot on. “There’s a reddish, colorado-maduro gleam to this dark cigar, whose creamy smoke is lush with fruity, ripe apple notes, molasses and brown sugar. The finish is long and spicy. Tasty and bold.”

    And don’t forget about the large volume of wonderfully aromatic smoke thats perfectly matched to its long finish. Ciao Bella!

    Wrapper: Honduran Habano
    Binder: Honduran
    Filler: Italian Habano Cuban Seed, Nicaraguan, Peruvian

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO World: ColombiaQuick View

    CAO World: Colombia

    $142.02$179.82

    CAO World: Colombia is one of this company’s very popular World Series.

    This highly rated cigar utilizes a unique blend of Colombian and Brazilian leaves found nowhere else. But the key to this amazing, medium bodied cigar is the Cameroon African binder. The cigar is well constructed and tightly packed from head to foot. Despite the amount of tobacco, this vitola has a wide open draw with a slow burn.

    When Cigar Aficionado gave it a score of 92, the industry took serious notice. Their review still holds up. ” A large, thick cigar that draws and burns evenly. It’s core of earth and wood is balanced by sweet, fruity notes of black cherry and nougat with a nutty touch of cashew.” What more do you need to know about this very exceptional cigar?

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: Nicaragua
    Binder: Cameroon
    Filler: Columbian and Brazilian
    Factory: STG Esteli
    Blender: Rick Rodriguez

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • CAO World: America

    $147.42$179.82

    CAO World: America is one of this company’s very popular World Series.

    Yes, you’re right! This terrific cigar has two different wrappers! It’s what we call a barber pole! Or in this case, more like a candy cane. With attention to detail, this highly rated cigar has a four country blend including rare tobacco from Italy! This America blend’s combination of fillers along with a twin Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper gives this smoke a very unique medium to full bodied taste with a bit of sweetness. Be Patriotic and give it a try!

    Origin – Honduras

    Wrappers: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro and Shade
    Binder: Brazil
    Filler: Ligero from Nicaragua, Dominican Republic, Italy, and USA

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO New Age: ConsigliereQuick View

    CAO New Age: Consigliere

    $167.22$197.82

    CAO New Age: Consigliere is a sequel or remake of sorts of the CAO “Sopranos” Cigar from the HBO series.

    Consigliere is handmade in Nicaragua, with a Brazilian Mata Fina wrapper, bound with a Honduran leaf and features a blend of Nicaraguan,Dominican and Colombian leaves. This complex four country blend produces a rich, balanced medium bodied smoke that burns smoothly to its finish. The results when the jury returned were….Cigar Aficionado @90, Cigar Coop @ 90 and Blind Man’s Puff @ 91. Looks like this CAO offering is one you can’t refuse!

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: Brazilian Mata Fina
    Binder: Honduras
    Filler: Nicaraguan, Dominican and Colombian
    Factory: STG Estelí
    Blender: Rick Rodriguez

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • CAO Flavours: Gold Honey

    $141.53$184.41

    Looking for something completely different? CAO Flavour editions are well made, very mild, nice diversions that can be appreciated and enjoyed for what they are.

    This Gold Honey style has a respectable three country tobacco blend that’s been infused with the nectar of orange blossom honey.

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Nicaraguan

    Binder – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Wrapper Type – Cameroon

    Shipping Restrictions:

    These items cannot be shipped to Massachusetts state addresses

  • CAO Flavours: Cherrybomb

    $95.22$184.41

    Looking for something completely different? CAO Flavour editions are well made, very mild, nice diversions that can be appreciated and enjoyed for what they are.

    This Cherrybomb style is just what it says. As soon as you light them up, you’re mouth is filled with a bunch of very defined cherry flavors.

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Dominican

    Binder – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Wrapper Type – Cameroon

    Shipping Restrictions:

    These items cannot be shipped to Massachusetts state addresses

  • CAO Flavours: Bella Vanilla

    $95.22$184.41

    Looking for something completely different? CAO Flavour editions are well made, very mild, nice diversions that can be appreciated and enjoyed for what they are.

    This Bella Vanilla style’s tobacco blend has been infused with the extract of Madagascar beans which are well known as being the Rolls Royce of the plant. Enough said.

    Origin – Dominican Republic

    Filler – Dominican

    Binder – Connecticut Broadleaf

    Wrapper Type – Cameroon

    Shipping Restrictions:

    These items cannot be shipped to Massachusetts state addresses

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO Classic: MaduroQuick View

    CAO Classic: Maduro

    $158.22$178.02

    CAO Classic: Maduro is formally known as the CAO L’Anniversaire Maduro.

    Its wrapper is fermented under extreme heat for three months until it becomes rich and dark with an even burn and razor-thin carbon ring. It’s then wrapped around an Ecuadoran binder and a blend of Nicaraguan and Dominican tobaccos to produce an outstanding smoke with a lavish finish.

    The result is a spectacular cigar standing the test of time for over 25 years. This is a medium plus to full bodied smoke is meant for seasoned smokers and passionados. Newcomers need not apply.

    Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
    Binder: Ecuador
    Filler: Nicaragua, Dominican Republic

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO Classic: Gold MaduroQuick View

    CAO Classic: Gold Maduro

    $158.22$176.22

    CAO Classic: Gold Maduro is the long awaited follow up to the original Gold entry.

    It took about ten years for CAO to come up with this darkly wrapped counterpart to their legendary gold line. Cigar Aficionado had kind words in 2007 for this flavorful and medium bodied maduro, as well. “Near black, this cigar has a solid core of sweet tobacco, complemented by nuts, coffee and a hint of leather on the finish.” It goes to show you that after 15 years, this cigar is still a winner!

    If you liked the original Gold, you’ll love this maduro!

    Origin:Nicaragua /  Filler:Nicaraguan /  Binder:Nicaraguan /  Wrapper:Brazilian Maduro

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    CAO Classic: CameroonQuick View

    CAO Classic: Cameroon

    $104.22$178.02

    CAO Classic: Cameroon is formally known as the CAO L’Anniversaire Cameroon.

    This amazing cigar was crafted by Nick Perdomo way back in  in 1999. Since then it has remained a hugely popular edition of the CAO lineup. Becoming one of Cigar Aficionado’s Top 50 Cigars and giving it a ’92’ rating, the magazine noted, “Nicely pressed, with rich color. The cigar has a lovely draw and burn. It’s nutty and toasty, with coffee, cocoa, and dry wood flavors. The finish is long.”

    If you consider yourself an aficionado and haven’t tried one of these amazing smokes, what are you waiting for? See what countless smokers have been enjoying for almost 25 years.

    Origin – Nicaragua

    Filler – Nicaraguan

    Binder – Nicaraguan

    Wrapper – Cameroon

    See all the CAO Cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Brioso Maduro

    $93.42$97.02

    This is another bundle of joy brought to us by cigar giant General Cigar. Here, the maker of Macanudo, CAO, Partagas to name a few gives us a great, medium bodied, everyday cigar for around 3 bucks. Unlike a zillion no-name brands, you can trust this company to deliver quality.

    Origin – Nicaragua

    Filler – Dominican-Honduran-Mexican-Nicaraguan

    Binder – Habano

    Wrapper Type – Maduro

  • Quorum Classic

    $39.24$60.84

    You know you’ve seen Quorums everywhere. What you may not know is that the Quorum Brand is the world’s best selling cigar! Brought to us by JC Newman, makers of Julius Caesar and Diamond Crown, the fact that all three styles have received a 92 rating while maintaining a value price point is more than enough to get your worthwhile attention.

    This well made Nicaraguan blended smoke is medium bodied is a terrific everyday cigar that you don’t mind throwing half of it away when you don’t have the time to finish it! The short Robusto size is affectionately known as a “Dog Walker”!

    WRAPPER: Sumatra Sungrown
    BINDER: Nicaraguan
    FILLER: Nicaraguan
    FACTORY: J.C. Newman

    RATINGS:
    Smoke Magazine: 92

  • La Unica Natural

    $124.20$145.80

    Origin – Dominican Republic
    Filler – Dominican
    Binder – Dominican
    Wrapper Type – Connecticut Shade

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Diamond Crown NaturalQuick View

    Diamond Crown Natural

    $172.13$305.10

    Diamond Crown cigars are true Super Premiums produced by J C Newman. Created by Master Blender Carlos Fuente Sr. using  5 year aged proprietary Connecticut Fermented Wrappers, this 92 rated cigar delivers one of the  smoothest flavor profiles available today. In short, this is mellow on a whole different level. Yes, they’re pricey but totally worth it.

    Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
    Wrapper: Connecticut Shade [CFW] “Connecticut Fermented Wrapper”
    Binder: Dominican Republic
    Filler: Caribbean, Central America
    Factory: Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cia
    Blender: Carlos Fuente Sr.

    RATINGS:
    Cigar Aficionado: 92
    Cigar & Spirits: 93
    Cigar Insider: 90
    Cigar Journal: 90
    Smoke Magazine: 93

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Diamond Crown MaximusQuick View

    Diamond Crown Maximus

    $229.50$368.10

    Diamond Crown Maximus is one of the true Super Premiums Cigars of the present day. Produced by J C Newman, this medium to full bodied Dominican beauty is wrapped with an Ecuadorian Sun Grown leaf that is almost too pretty to light up!  The uncanny characteristic about this stick is that it is super smooth from start to finish. We know they’re expensive but assure you they are worth it.

    Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
    Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sungrown
    Binder: Dominican Republic
    Filler: Dominican Republic
    Factory: Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cia
    Blender: Carlos Fuente

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Diamond Crown MaduroQuick View

    Diamond Crown Maduro

    $172.13$305.10

    Diamond Crown cigars are true Super Premiums made by J C Newman.  The Maduro edition’s wrapper has been triple fermented giving it an oily, dark sheen adding just a bit of robustness to it as compared with it’s Natural counterpart.

    Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro
    Binder: Dominican
    Filler: Selection of 5 different fillers from the Caribbean and Central America

    RATINGS:
    Cigar & Spirits: 92
    Cigar Journal: 93
    Cigar Snob: 91
    Smoke Magazine: 90

  • Out Stock
    Sale!
    Quick View

    Cuesta Rey Centro Fino

    $69.75$90.90

    Now I know you’re really looking for a unique cigar!

    Brought to us from JC Newman, the Cuesta Rey line has been around forever. In fact, King Alfonso XIII of Spain who ruled from the late 1800’s to the early 1900’s declared it his favorite! The Dominican filler picked from the center of the plants has been aged five years. The wrapper is grown on Oliva’s Ecuadorian farm. The cigars are then aged in Spanish Cedar lined cabinets. The result is a stick with a medium to full bodied taste as rich as it’s heritage. This is one of my favorite “Old School” brands. Step back in time and try some of these great sticks!

    Origin – Coming Soon!

    Filler – Coming Soon!

    Binder – Coming Soon!

    Wrapper Type – Coming Soon!

  • Brick House Classic

    $130.00$181.12

    Brick House Classic- The first thing you have to know about the Brick House brand is that its brought to us from JC Newman, The purveyors of the Julius Caesar and Diamond Crown Super Premiums. When Brick House came onto the scene in 2010 it was listed as one of the top 25 cigars of the year. Six years later when it was reviewed again it received a 93 rating. It’s safe to say that 10 years later, every savvy tobacconist’s humidor has Brick House available.

    This well constructed cigar yields a large volume of medium to full bodied flavor with a consistently perfect draw.

    WRAPPER: Ecuadorian Havana BINDER: Nicaraguan FILLER: Nicaraguan FACTORY: J.C. Newman

    RATINGS:
    Cigar Aficionado: Top 25 Cigars of 2010 and 2016
    Cigar & Spirits: 92
    Cigar Journal: 93
    Cigar Snob: 91
    Smoke Magazine: 90

    Check out the Brick House Maduro!

  • Arturo Fuente It’s A Boy

    $71.00

    CONGRATULATIONS…….to anyone celebrating this blessed event! If you’re looking to pass out a cigar that’s more than a token celebratory stick, what better brand can you pick! , Arturo Fuente has produced the medium bodied economical Breva for decades. These branded favorites will definitely add class to your very special occasion!

    Box Count: 25
    Wrapper: Cameroon
    Binder: Dominican
    Filler: Dominican

  • Joya De Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco

    $73.39$114.39

    Joya De Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco was created in 2015 to celebrate the company’s 45th anniversary.

    With attention to detail, the 5 year old tobaccos are stored in oak barrels and continue to age producing a complex, medium-full bodied smoke with amazing flavors. Giving it a respectable 92 rating, Cigar Aficionado’s description is short and sweet” Box-pressed with a full draw. The cigar starts sweet with hints of molasses that segue into spicier elements and big notes of hickory.”

    With this in mind, it’s no surprise why so many seasoned smokers are rediscovering this time honored brand. Cuatro Cinco stick is still one of today’s true Luxury cigars.

    See all the Drew Estate brands available on The Cigar Thief HERE

    Wrapper: Nicaraguan Criollo
    Binder: Dominican
    Filler: Nicaraguan
    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Factory: Fábrica de Tabacos Joya de Nicaragua SA

     

  • Joya De Nicaragua Antano Gran Reserva

    $164.00$188.60

    Joya De Nicaragua Antano Gran Reserva is one of this iconic company’s great achievements. In fact, it could be said that when this entry came to market, many, many newcomers gave it a try and loved it.

    In 2018 the expertly box pressed Gran Reserva line was rated 93 by Cigar Aficionado and placed #16 as one of the best cigars of the year! While this masterfully made cigar contains the same overall blend used in the Original, all the leaves were allowed to age a long, long time. The results are all the signature characteristics of the Original with a smoother, medium bodied taste creating a tamer, friendlier smoke that everyone can enjoy. And enjoy that have…..and still are to this day!

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua
    Wrapper: Nicaragua Oscuro
    Binder: Nicaragua
    Filler: Nicaragua
    Factory: Fabrica de Tabacos Joya de Nicaragua S.A.
    Blender: Juan Martinez, Alejandro Martinez Cuenca

    FYI: No matter what strength, taste and body your palate prefers, there’s a Joya blended with you in mind. Check out all the other Joya De Nicaragua cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

  • Joya De Nicaragua Antano Dark Corojo

    $121.36$177.12

    Joya De Nicaragua Antano Dark Corojo is yet another one of this iconic company’s great achievements.

    This perfectly made Antano Dark Corojo cigar is wrapped with a specially grown Corojo leaf and contains 3-year aged Nicaraguan long-filler tobaccos. The result is a strictly full flavored robust smoke that’s refined, satisfying and uncommonly smooth. With a doubt, getting a 90 rating from Cigar Aficionado led to many seasoned smokers seeing what this great cigar was all about. With this in mind, if you truly feel you’re a connoisseur, Antano Dark Corojo should be in your humidor for sure!

    Wrapper: Nicaraguan Corojo Oscuro
    Binder: Nicaragua [Aged 3 years]
    Filler: Nicaragua [Aged 3 years]

    No matter what strength, taste and body your palate prefers, there’s a Joya blended with you in mind. In fact there are now 24 varieties in the line. Check all the other Joya De Nicaragua cigars available on The Cigar Thief HERE

     

  • Herrera Esteli Brazilian Maduro

    $174.25$227.55

    This masterfully crafted Herrera Esteli Brazilian Maduro  proves yet again just how great Willy is at blending cigars. Herrera himself describes this complex cigar perfectly. “With the Brazilian Maduro, I wanted to bring the Mata Fina to the forefront of this blend. This tobacco has such a unique texture and it showcases the lush floral and earthy notes I wanted to capture in this cigar. In addition, now that the Herrera Esteli line has been repackaged blending modern simplicity with classic Cuban style, it really shines on our retailers’ shelves and brings unity to the brand.”

    With  Cigar Authority rating it at 91 and Stogie Press at 92, there’s no doubt that this Brazilian Maduro is another winner,

    Country of Origin: Nicaragua 

    Wrapper: Brazilian Mata Fina
    Binder: Connecticut Broadleaf
    Filler: Nicaraguan
    Factory: La Gran Fabrica Drew Estate
    Blender:Willy Herrera